A priest whose name is not now known was installed by Geoffrey de Mandeville

Carshalton, which had been five manors under King Edward the Confessor, was given by William the Conqueror as one manor to Geoffrey de Mandeville; the Lord of the Manor probably had the right to select clergy for the local church.

Pharamus de Boulogne transferred the advowson (the right to choose a priest) for Carshalton plus the right to Tithes to Merton Priory. Priors of Merton were "Rector" of Carshalton until the Priory was dissolved.

Alanus Presbyter was priest, having been installed by Faramus de Boulogne.

Hugo de Kersawelton was priest, having been installed by Merton Priory.

Walter Capellanus was priest, having been installed by Merton Priory

Roger de Patrikesburn was priest, having been installed by Merton Priory.

William de Hatferd

William de Hovingham was installed, having been appointed by Edward I on 5 May 1306

Walter de Walsokne

Roger Cole

William de Middleton[18] (priested 22 Sep 1347)

Roger de Sileby (or Dalby)

Walter Lucas

Richard de Gretton, appointed by Edward III

Peter de Estrodeham (alias Chekyn)

Peter Barbour or Barbon (until 1392)

Nicholas Asser (until 1394)

John Gernays or Gervays, appointed by John de Uvedale (until 1395)

Richard Priour

John Barbour of Milton Kaynes

Nicholas Vyrly, appointed by Henry IV (until 3 August 1408)

Robert Grene

John Aynulph, MA

Henry Bynne (or Lynne) (until 1452)

Peter Barron (until 1472)

John Clerk (until 1472)

no record of an appointment

John Clerk

John Persburgge (or Percebrigg) (died 1474)

John Hylle

John Leeke, released from Erdebury Priory, Warwickshire by papal bull of Pope Alexander VI in order to take up a parish appointment.

A replica of a tomb fragment in the Lady Chapel shows Walter Gaynesford, Chaplain, who died on 10 May 1493, in mass vestments.

Richard Meltham 

Edmund Haltman (until 1536)

Miles Braithwaite MA (the last vicar appointed by Merton Priory) (until 1543)

After the Dissolution of Merton Priory in 1538 (or perhaps 1540) King Edward VI had the advowson (the right to choose a priest) until 1552; then it was bought and sold privately until 1961. All of the owners except royalty were related to Nicholas Gaynesford, buried in the Lady Chapel.

John Bayly (appointed by Henry VIII, resigned with effect from January 1549 when the first Book of Common Prayer was introduced)

Robert Brinknell (or Richard Brinknell, appointed by Edward VI)

Thomas Abbott MA, appointed by Sir William Goringe (until 1553)

Roger Norwode BA appointed by Sir William Goringe (until 1554)

Richard Redworth MA (or Redworthe), appointed by Sir William Goringe

Randulph or Ranulph Becket, appointed by John Fromond

Robert Eston, appointed by John Fromond.

Daniel Edwards, appointed by John Fromond (died 1571)

John ap Peers, a Welshman from Flintshire, appointed by John Fromond.

Peter Dawson or Danson MA, appointed by Mrs Sanchia Byne, Mrs Elizabeth Palmer and Mrs Susan Mowne, who moved in 1618 to become Vicar of Camberwell in place of his uncle who had died.

William Quelche BD, appointed by Edward Blower; his memorial in the Lady Chapel says he was "a certain Fryer some times Vicar of this place" up to his death on 10 April 1654.

no entries for which Revd William Quelch wrote a fulsome apology on 10 March 1651; this was a time of great upheaval and in 1644 Parliament branded Revd Peter Dawson (above) a malignant papist and royalist, and removed him from his living.

William Parkes, appointed by Charles Burton

Isaac Cowper, appointed by Henry Byne I, possibly not a priest but installed temporarily

Thomas Bradley MA DD, whose monument is in the south aisle, appointed by the Henry Byne I who refused to vow allegiance to William of Orange; Thomas therefore refused too, and was expelled from the living in 1689.

John Nelme BA, appointed to both Beddington and Carshalton by his father-in-law Henry Byne II, who was the last Lay Rector of Carshalton; Henry then gave the vicars half of the rectorial tithes which enabled them to become the kind of Rector we know today.

William Hillier or Hollier BA MA, appointed by Henry Byne II

Edmund Lodge BA MA, appointed by Henry Byne II who was made rector as part of the settlement of a property dispute with the Byne family; he left Carshalton in 1759 when he was promoted to Archdeacon.

Robert Gilbert MA DD, appointed by Ann and Henry Byne II (died 30 November 1776)

William Rose MA, FRS, appointed by Joseph Rose, died 1829 and commemorated in the Lady Chapel.

Charles Cator MA BD, appointed by John Cator imprisoned for debt and forced to resign in 1835

William Hardy Vernon MA, appointed by John Cator, but his cousin Revd Charles Cator was still officially Rector, so perhaps William was Vicar (until 1845)

William Albemarle B. Cator MA appointed by Albemarle Cator, highly regarded, despite his repetitive services, for his generous spirit and excellent sermons; he was com­mem­orated in 1894 by a new chancel east window; his uncle the Revd Charles Cator was still officially Rector in 1849, so perhaps William was Vicar. Bishop Anthony Thorold of Rochester visited Carshalton on 15th July 1881 and wrote that the Rector was "a queer odd tempered man, yet not without good humour, and manageable if dextrously handled, is under the impression his parish is one of the best worked in the diocese ... I can't help liking him..."

Lord Victor A Seymour MA, b.1859 fourth son of the 5th Marquess of Hertford, married Elizabeth Cator; he was keen on ecumenism and (controversially) Reservation of the Blessed Sacrament; d.1935, com­mem­orated in:

• a Lady Chapel wall monument, commemorating the donation of...

• ...the Lady Chapel window stained glass,

• a family dedication in the Lady Chapel south east window,

• Sir Ninian Comper's decoration of the 17th cnetury Grinling Gibbons reredos in the Lady Chapel,

• and in the name of a local Infant school (now part of Greenshaw Learning Trust).

George P Trevelyan

George Bower Vaux MA (until 1919)​

Extension of the church completed in 1914

William Robert Corbould: b. 1880, an extreme anglo-catholic (servers' nickname "Bob")

Organ moved to present position and all of the embellishments by Sir Ninian Comper (churchwarden) completed during these years

Leigh Cameron Edwards MA b. 1917 (servers' nickname "Taffy").  During his Incumbnecy, the Churchyard was closed to new burials.

The right to choose a priest for the parish was given by the owner to the Bishops of Southwark

John Charles Thewlis BA PhD b.1949, who described himself as "an historian" and played the organ at about 25% of the services

David Stephen Fisher BTh (Oxon) SCP (formerlly Canon Precentor of Bangor Cathedral; licensed first as Priest-in-Charge 13 September 2018)